This is an article I wrote in the mid-90s. It was almost published in Martial Arts Training magazine. (There was a problem with the photos.) Here it is with minor edits. Note that we still do this drill every week!
It is not uncommon for martial artists to demonstrate their defensive prowess against punches by saying "Throw a left jab" or "Okay, try to hit me with a right hook." The result might be a forceful block followed by a series of lightning counters, or a gap too wide to allow the punch to reach followed by an impressive kick combination. While such displays may be entertaining, they have nothing to do with defending against a real attack. The problem is not with the defense but with the foreknowledge of the attacking technique.
The Punch Defenses Drill (PDD) provides martial artists with a progressive test of defensive ability under sub-optimal conditions that more closely approach reality than traditional one-step sparring or similarly static exercises. It can give a new, possibly disturbing, perspective on the relative effectiveness of various defensive techniques.
Continue reading